Design Graphic Design Typography

JPJ 1: A Standardised Number Plate Typeface for Malaysia

In 2018, peeved with the variation in number plate typefaces used by vehicles in Malaysia, I published an article (here previously) showcasing 3 typefaces that I designed as possible standardised options for car number plates in Malaysia (Figure 1, below). A monograph on the same topic was written and published in early 2019. Later that year I conducted a Twitter poll for feedback (read more here), the results led to the redesigning of the ubiquitous Factory Manufactured Typeface (FMT) used on number plates by most vehicles in Malaysia (Figure 2).

Figure 1. Myno, Myno Extended and Nomy number plate typefaces. © Vinod J. Nair 2018.
Figure 2. The Factory Manufactured Typeface (FMT) is made of white plastic with a slightly bevelled edge. These are affixed onto a black plastic base plate using an adhesive solution. The typeface does not exist digitally as a font and is only available from license plate makers in hardcopy format.

Before I begin, it is important to clarify that the terms ‘vehicle number plate’ or ‘vehicle license plate’ are one and the same. They both refer to the plate that houses the vehicle’s ‘license registration’, which is a combination of letters of the alphabet and numerals (alphanumeric), i.e. WNE 3314. The display of a vehicle’s license registration in Malaysia is governed by the Road Transport Act 333 (1987, p. 38), section 20 (Display of motor vehicle license). However, unlike Singapore, the precise particulars of this display have not been articulated in detail and elucidated in diagrams and therefore encoded in law via the act. That said, the Road Transport Department (RTD or known by its Malay name Jabatan Pengangkutan Jalan aka JPJ) has issued rules governing the display of vehicle registrations on license plates through its website (plate number specification). Here, the numeral sizes, colour, and even fonts are indicated in two brief diagrams. The fonts depicted in the diagrams are Calisto MT Italic and Franklin Gothic Bold (Figure 3). Whether this is a recommendation or rule is uncertain because in practice the typeface used by a majority of vehicles in Malaysia, is the FMT seen above in Figure 2. The FMT is a factory manufactured white plastic alphanumeric that is 70mm high and approximately 3mm in depth. It has been in use for decades and is not available digitally.

Figure 3. Number Plate Specification on the RTD website detailing the measurements of height, width, inter-letter spacing, line-spacing and the type of fonts used for car and motorcycles.

The fonts Calisto MT Italic and Franklin Gothic Bold are not fonts that were designed specifically for use as number plate typefaces. There is also the concern as to whether the RTD has obtained the license to use the said fonts. I suspect the choice not to feature the FMT, which has the widest usage, in the “Number Plate Specification” diagram (Figure 3) is due to the fact that the typeface does not exist in digital form. It would be unfair to fault the RTD in its choice, as knowledge on typeface selection or appropriateness isn’t within their area of expertise. In countries that have design awareness, these areas are governed by design policies and entrusted to national design councils to advise and or execute. Thus far, there are four countries in Asia that have design policies; Japan, South Korea, India and Singapore (International Council of Design, 2015). While Malaysia has a government funded design council known as MRM (Majlis Rekabentuk Malaysia) under the Ministry of International Trade and Industry (MOSTI) its voice or role in government, I suspect, is unclear to other government agencies. The lack of awareness amongst agencies in government on how and where design can assist in areas of governance, is still a major stumbling block.

So why is there a need to have a standard typeface for vehicle number plates in Malaysia when abuse could still occur despite having standards? Well, the simple answer to that is that the lack of clear standards leaves room for a larger number of abuses i.e. “custom”, “fancy”, or “personalized” number plates. Standards are important for there to be coherence and clarity in the application of the rule of law. Countries like Germany, Italy, Singapore, UK and many more, all have standardised number plate typefaces and clear display guidelines. A standard number plate typeface will also allow for technologies like Automatic License Plate Recognition (ALPR) to be more effective for tracking and enforcement.

In Malaysia it is abundantly clear that the majority of vehicles use the FMT, and it is ‘RTD approved’ in practice albeit not featured in written law or in rules on number plate display. For a designer hoping to lend his expertise in this situation, it would have been a relatively easy task to replicate the FMT, as is. While the FMT has its merits, there is room for improvement. Therefore, this is what I set out to do with my revised and redesigned version (Figure 4) of the FMT, which I have named “JPJ 1”. To do so, I first began by analysing the FMT.

Figure 4. JPJ 1, is a new and improved number plate typeface, designed by Vinod J. Nair. It is based around the proportions of the existing Factory Manufactured Typeface (FMT) used in vehicle license plates in Malaysia. © Vinod J. Nair, 2020.

The FMT has a proportion that mirrors a ‘rustic capital’ in that it is condense in form but yet relatively open in face and heavily rounded. To its advantage it is legible and familiar to a great many Malaysians. It is my belief that familiarity and legibility in this case are phenomena that are interdependent or intertwined, the more familiar the typeface the more legible it may seem, and therefore easily recognisable and identifiable. There are studies on familiarity bias that so indicate. By and large the FMT conforms to the most important need, which is legibility.

To improve on the FMT I first had to deconstruct the alphanumeric (figure 5). In analysing the FMT, it became clear that the artist based the forms on a 4 × 7 grid that reflected the thickness of the uniformed strokes. All the numbers and letters were derived from this discovered grid. Thus the FMT has a relatively consistent width and stroke thickness. This has resulted in some compromises seen in capital letters N, W and M, which under usual circumstances are wider.

Figure 5. (Top Left and right) The FMT is constructed on a 4 × 7 grid and has a fixed width. The deconstruction of the FMT reveals the rudimentary and utilitarian nature of its construction. (Top right) The discovered grid structure is broken down into horizontal, vertical and circular lines on a 4 × 7 grid that is based on the thickness of the FMT stroke’s width. (Bottom Left) Shapes constructed on the FMT’s 4 × 7 grid structure. (Bottom right) The letters M, W & N are normally wider but in the FMT the artist has tried to maintain a single width (monospace).
Figure 6. Deconstruction of some FMT numerals 8, 9, 6, 4 & 7 based on the discovered grid. Analysis of the numerals 6, 4 and 7 reveal some of the thought processes or decision behind the construction of the FMT; how the closed counter of the 6 breaches the mid-point by half a square; how the vertical stem stroke of the 4 occupies the mid-section of the last two columns; and the decision to implement curved strokes for 4 & 7. One can almost imagine a technical artist using a compass to draw these forms on the grid or graph.

In its construction, the FMT’s numeral 8 is based on two equal sized circles while the number 9 and 6 counters are half a square larger in most instances (Figure 6). From this visual analysis of the FMT, the original artist did an acceptable job in its construction. However, the artist also ignored some time-tested conventions in typeface design. For example, the open and closed counters in the FMT 3, 8, and B (Figure 7) are equal in size, as a result the forms seem top-heavy. This visual dissonance occurs simply because of the way our brain deciphers visual information. As per convention, the solution is to reduce the size of the upper story open and closed counter to address this optical illusion (Figure 8).

Figure 7. The white highlight indicates what is referred to as the “upper story open and close counters” of the FMT.
Figure 8. (Top left) Note the upper and lower story counters for the FMT alphanumeric 3, 8 & B are equal in size resulting in visual dissonance that makes the alphanumeric seem top-heavy. (Top right) JPJ 1’s upper story counters are smaller when compared to the bottom counters, giving the numeral a firm footing and steadier demeanour. In addition, the introduction of rounded edges caters for metal embossing. (Bottom) Side by side comparison of alphanumeric 3, 8 and B (FMT: left, and JPJ 1: right).

In addition to the above, contrast and ink traps were introduced into JPJ 1 with the intention to boost readability and legibility. Ink traps were originally conceived by Mathew Carter when designing the typeface Bell Centennial, it “compensated for the amount of ink spread that occurs when printing on low quality paper at high speeds”. The ink trap would retain features of the letterform under adverse conditions. With this in mind, the same principle could be achieved with JPJ 1 so that it retains its core characteristics at distance when blurred (Figure 9). As objects are further away they tend to look blurry because of particles in the air that obscure the clarity of the object. Thus, contrast and ink traps were introduced for the alphabets M, W, V, N and more (Figure 11).

Figure 9: Top left (1) FMT original W, top right (2) JPJ 1’s W with ink traps. Note that ink traps were introduced in the vertex and apex areas of the letter form (bottom left, 3). The results — when simulating distance — can be seen in the bottom right (4) square: where the W on the left (FMT) and the W on the right (JPJ 1) are placed side by side for comparison. The distance simulation showcases evidence of JPJ 1’s greater retention of the apex and vertex areas making it potentially more visible or clearer at distance.
Figure 10. W’s of FMT (left) and JPJ 1 (right): Simulation at distance enlarged to understand how the ink traps in JPJ 1 allows for greater legibility and retention of core features in JPJ 1’s W. While these may seem to be very minor, under certain conditions this may be the difference needed for identification.
Figure 11. Letters M, W, V, N from JPJ 1 number plate typeface with ink traps featured. This feature was introduced in other letters as well.

When JPJ 1 was conceived it was primarily aimed for use on number plates in Malaysia. However, I realised that there are other countries in the region and internationally that did not have a standard for their vehicle number plate typeface. Thus, an entire Latin character set that included international glyphs with punctuation was developed (Figure 13).

Figure 12. Top FMT, bottom JPJ 1. Apart from the introduction of punctuation and an international character set, changes were introduced in many of the alphanumeric, some obvious others subtle. These changes were to increase legibility and readability, address visual dissonance and or to adhere to good type design practice. This has resulted in a new, improved and professional looking typeface in the form of JPJ 1.

This year (May 2021) the issue of standardisation was raised (once again) by Bukit Aman criminal investigation department director Datuk Huzir Mohamed and this was reported by news portals. Having worked on this since 2017, I emailed my proposal to Datuk Huzir and The RTD Director Dato’ Zailani Hj. Hashim. In response the RTD Director informed me that he will raise the matter (again) with Putrajaya, the Malaysian government’s administrative capital. He went on to mention that this matter has been raised and deliberated since 2016 but was postponed due to unspecified reasons.

I suspect the reasons for the repeated delays, which may or may not be justified, is due to the complexity of the system being deliberated and the cost factors involved. The issue is much bigger than just a typeface. The typeface is one very small component of larger “Intelligent Transport System” (ITS) that is being worked out by the Ministry of Transport (MOT). The deliberations involve several enforcement and administrative agencies and many different technologies. RFID number plates, Automatic Number Plate Recognition (ANPR), vehicle On-board Unit Systems, Global Navigation Satellite System are all different types of “Vehicle Identification Systems” that are being considered. These involve infrastructure costs that are in the millions. The MOT is in favour of RFID (active and passive) number plates since 2017, used in combination with ANPR. So far, there has been no discernible action on the Malaysian ITS Blueprint 2019 with regard to the above, and in relation to vehicle license plate display format and the number plate typeface.

In closing, I believe the JPJ 1 number plate typeface that I designed has potential due to its familiarity and relatability, the innovative introduction of ink traps to improve legibility and readability at distance, the rounded corners to facilitate metal embossing, a wider range of Latin characters for international adaptability, a digital typeface for use to develop RTD diagrams, and a national vehicle number plate display format that improves upon the current format and considers cross-border identification. This offers JPJ 1 not just as a solution, but a designed solution.

TYPE YOUR VEHICLE NUMBER HERE

 

Figure 13. Full set of JPJ 1 typeface, with punctuation and additional Latin international characters in uppercase.
Figure 14.
Figure 15. JPJ 1 car number plate display specifications with black and white flag and the country’s abbreviated initials as identification markings for cross-border travel.
Figure 16. JPJ 1 motorcycle number plate display specifications
Figure 17. Simulation: German, Finland, Great Britain and Malaysian number plates, using JPJ 1
Fig 24. Simulation of Taxi, Diplomatic core and Malaysian military number plates using JPJ 1.
Figure 20. Simulation using JPJ 1 with Malaysian state flags on vehicle number plates. The state badges have been simplified for use as small sized icons.
Figure 21. Simulation of “Persons With Disability” sign on vehicle number plate using JPJ 1.
Figure 22. Simulation of “Electric Vehicle (EV)” number plate using JPJ 1.
JPJ1, © Vinod J. Nair, 2020.

I’d like to thank José Rodríguez from Texas (USA), for his technical insights on number plate designs. He can be contacted here.

7 comments

  1. Love this. Learned so much about something we take for granted but in actual fact, has tentacles in governmental policies and legalities.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: